Who to Pick First in Fantasy Baseball: A Comprehensive Guide

It’s fantasy baseball season, and that means it’s time to start thinking about who to pick first in your draft. There are a lot of factors to consider, but this comprehensive guide will help you make the best decision for your team.


In fantasy baseball, as in real baseball, the goal is to put together a team of players who will accumulate the most statistical categories (known as “categories” or “cats”) over the course of a season. There are many different ways to go about this, but the most important thing is to have a plan.

There are two schools of thought on how to approach drafting in fantasy baseball:
1) You can draft the best player available regardless of position (known as “Best Player Available,” or BPA), or
2) you can draft for need, choosing the best player available at a position you need to fill (known as “Position scarcity”).

There is no right or wrong answer here; it’s all about what works for you and your particular draft strategy. In general, if you are drafting in a standard 5×5 league (see below), you will want to focus on filling up your hitting categories first and foremost. Once you have done that, you can start thinking about pitching.

standard 5×5 fantasy baseball leagues use these statistical categories:
– batting average
– home runs
– runs batted in (RBI)
– stolen bases
– wins
– strikeouts
– saves

The Strategy

It’s fantasy baseball season and you’re in your league’s draft. Who do you pick first? It’s a tough decision with so many good players to choose from. Here is a comprehensive guide to help you make the best decision for your team.

Evaluating Categories

There are many ways to win in fantasy baseball, but the most common path to victory is by building a team that dominates one or two specific statistical categories. In order to do this, you need to have a clear understanding of which categories are the most important in your league. This can vary depending on the scoring system, so it’s important to know what you’re looking for before drafting your team.

For example, in a standard 5×5 roto league, the categories are typically batting average, home runs, runs batted in, stolen bases, and ERA. In this type of league, it’s usually best to focus on building a team that excels in batting average and power categories like home runs and RBIs. This is because these categories tend to be the most consistent from year to year, and they also have the biggest impact on your team’s overall standings.

On the other hand, in a points-based league, the scoring system is typically different and places more emphasis on individual statistics rather than team totals. In this type of league, it might be more beneficial to target players who excel in multiple categories instead of focusing on just one or two. This is because points-based leagues tend to reward players who are well-rounded and contribute in multiple ways.

No matter what type of league you’re playing in, it’s important to understand which categories are most important so that you can draft accordingly. By knowing which players will help you dominate specific categories, you’ll be well on your way to winning your fantasy baseball league.

Evaluating Players

We all want to know who the sleepers are and who we should target in our drafts, but in order to do that, we need to first understand how to evaluate players. This can be a difficult task, as there are many factors to consider when trying to project future fantasy baseball success. In this article, we will break down the different aspects of player evaluation so that you can make well-informed decisions come draft day.

The first step in evaluating players is to understand the different types of statistics that are used to measure performance. The three most important statistical categories for hitters are batting average, home runs, and runs batted in (RBI). For pitchers, the three most important categories are earned run average (ERA), strikeouts per nine innings pitched (K/9), and walks plus hits per inning pitched (WHIP). There are other important statistics to consider as well, but these six categories should be given the most weight when making your decisions.

Once you know which statistics are important, you need to decide how much weight to give each one. This is where personal preference comes into play; some people place a higher value on batting average than home runs, while others might do the opposite. The important thing is that you are consistent in your approach so that you can accurately compare players across different positions.

After you have decided which statistics are most important and how much weight to give each one, it is time to start looking at specific players. A good place to start is with last year’s stats, but keep in mind that these numbers only tell part of the story. Players can get hot or cold at any time, so it is important not to put too much stock into one particular season’s numbers. Instead, look at a player’s career numbers to get a more accurate picture of his true skill set.

When comparing two players, it is also important to consider their playing time. A player who hits .300 with 20 home runs but only plays in 120 games is not as valuable as a player who hits .280 with 15 home runs but plays in 150 games. This is because the latter player will have more opportunities to accumulate counting stats like home runs and RBI.

Remember, there is no perfect formula for determining which players will be the best fantasy baseball assets; it ultimately comes down to personal preference and gut feeling. However, if you follow the steps outlined above, you should be able to make informed decisions come draft day.

The Draft

Fantasy baseball is a game in which fans act as the general managers of virtual professional baseball teams. The objective of each team is to score the most points possible. Points are based on the actual statistical performance of the players in real-life games. In order to score the most points, it is important to have a strong team. A team can be strong in a number of ways, but one of the most important is through a strong draft.

The First Pick

There is no science to who you should take with the first pick in a snake draft. The first pick is usually reserved for the best player in the game, but that doesn’t mean you should take Mike Trout if you’re drafting last. Rather, you should take the best player available regardless of position. If Trout is available when you pick, there’s no reason not to take him.

Some experts may tell you to take a pitcher with your first pick because they’re more valuable than hitters, but this isn’t always the case. It really depends on the league you’re in and how important stolen bases are. In a standard 5x5rotisserie league, Trout is still the best player available. In a points league, however, Clayton Kershaw may be the better choice because he provides more value in terms of strikeouts and wins. Ultimately, it’s up to you to decide who the best player is in your league.

If you’re having trouble deciding who to take with your first pick, don’t worry – there are plenty of great players to choose from. Just remember to take the best player available regardless of position and you’ll be off to a great start!

The Second Pick

In a snake draft, the order of the draft is determined by a random draw and the order goes from round to round (1-n, n-1, 1-n, n-1, etc.). In an auction draft, every team has a set budget (usually $200) that they use to fill out their rosters. In both cases, you want to have the second pick. Why? Because you can snag the best player in the league.

The first pick in a snake draft is pretty easy to predict. It will either be Mike Trout or Mookie Betts. In an auction draft, whoever spends the most on Trout or Betts will get them. So, if you have the second pick in either type of draft, you can take whichever player is left over. In a snake draft, that’s usually Nolan Arenado or Jose Altuve. In an auction draft, it could be anyone depending on how much the person with the first pick spends on Trout or Betts.

Having the second pick gives you a big advantage because you can get one of the best players in baseball without having to use up your entire budget or using up a high draft pick.

The Third Pick

The third pick in a fantasy baseball draft is a bit of a sweet spot. By this point, most of the top tier players are off the board, but there are still plenty of solid options to choose from.

In an auction draft, the third pick is a good time to start bidding on middle-tier players. These are guys who are good enough to be starters on your team, but aren’t going to break the bank.

In a snake draft, the third pick is a good time to start filling out your starting lineup. If you went with two outfielders in the first two rounds, this is a good time to grab a third baseman or shortstop. If you already have a full infield, this is a good time to start stockpiling outfielders.

Some players who could be available at the third pick include:

Mookie Betts, OF, Boston Red Sox
Betts is one of the best all-around players in baseball. He’s got a strong batting average and power numbers, and he’s also a threat on the base paths. He’s also eligible for multiple positions, which makes him even more valuable.

Jose Ramirez, 3B/2B/OF, Cleveland Indians
Ramirez is another versatile player who can fill multiple positions on your roster. He’s coming off back-to-back seasons with over 30 home runs and 100 RBIs, so he’s certainly got the power numbers you’re looking for.

Mike Trout, OF, Los Angeles Angels
Trout is arguably the best player in baseball, so he’s certainly worth consideration with the third pick. He’s got elite power and batting average numbers, and he also steals his fair share of bases. The only downside is that he doesn’t have eligibility at multiple positions.


In conclusion, there is no definitive answer to the question of who to pick first in fantasy baseball. The best course of action is to research the league settings and scoring system, as well as the player pool, in order to make an informed decision.

Ultimately, the goal is to assemble a team that will score the most points possible within the given parameters. With a little bit of planning and forethought, it is possible to put together a competitive squad that has a good chance of success.

Similar Posts